Vitamin D vs Omega-3

for mood

Stronger evidence: tie

Stronger effect: Omega-3

Safety: Omega-3 has the more serious interaction profile (minor vs serious).

For mood, the two are evidence-matched; the difference is in effect and safety.

Vitamin D

grade C low certainty

small mood benefit, mostly in people who are deficient

Omega-3

grade C moderate certainty

small benefit for depressive symptoms, clearest with higher-EPA formulations

1–2 g EPA, adults with depression
sources: PMID:00000005 · PMID:20000102