Methodology critique
A methodology nobody has attacked is a methodology nobody has tested. We invite named, substantive critique from evidence-synthesis methodologists, supplement researchers, and clinical pharmacologists — and publish it here unedited, including the critiques we accepted and acted on. Especially those.
How to critique this methodology
- Read the published methodology — grading rubric, GRADE/RoB2/PRISMA anchoring, absence states, re-review SLA.
- Send your critique with your name and affiliation (or state you're an independent researcher).
- We publish every substantive critique here, unedited, with our response — whether we agree or not.
- Where we accept a critique, the resulting methodology version bump cites it directly.
Log
No critique received yet. We're publishing the invitation and this page before the first response arrives — the same honest-zero discipline as our corrections log.